Exhibit · Email

Karin Vaal­burg, Na­tion­al Om­buds­man, to Giltay, emails, 8 January to 21 Feb­ru­ary 2024

The quotation in the Voices section joins two messages from the same adviser: her verdict on the book from her email of 9 January 2024, and the words “with great pleasure” from her email of 21 February 2024. Both passages are set out below, in the order in which they were written.

Her message of 9 January 2024

“I did indeed read your book (the PDF you sent me, thank you again for that!) in full during my Christmas leave. My com­pli­ments on the very extensive un­der­ly­ing doc­u­men­ta­tion and level of detail in the story! All being well, you will now receive the documents you asked for (from your own file) within 2 weeks. Perhaps we could then make an ap­point­ment to discuss your file. How would you feel about that?” Page 4, the message of 9 January 2024, 14:11, quoted further down the thread. The passage forms one paragraph of the message, which is signed “Karin Vaalburg, Senior juridisch adviseur” (‘senior legal adviser’). The first bracketed remark in the passage refers to the PDF of the book that Giltay had sent her himself. The last two sentences run on as a single sentence in Dutch, joined by a comma; the translation splits them. Translated from the Dutch; the original wording is below.

“Uw boek (de pdf die u mij heeft gestuurd, nogmaals dank daarvoor!) heb ik inderdaad helemaal gelezen tijdens het kerstverlof. Mijn com­pli­men­ten voor de zeer uitgebreide ach­ter­lig­gen­de do­cu­men­ta­tie en ge­de­tail­leerd­heid van het verhaal! Als het goed is ontvangt u nu binnen 2 weken de door u op­ge­vraag­de documenten (van uw eigen dossier). Wellicht dat wij daarna een afspraak kunnen maken om uw dossier te bespreken, hoe staat u daar tegenover?” Original wording

The paragraph in the email of 9 January 2024, in Dutch, in which the Ombudsman’s senior legal adviser writes that she did indeed read the PDF of the book in full during her Christmas leave. She compliments the very extensive underlying documentation and the level of detail in the story. She also says that the documents from Giltay’s own file should reach him within two weeks, and asks how he would feel about making an appointment afterwards to discuss that file.
Extract from page 4 of the email thread: the message of 9 January 2024. Tap the image to enlarge.

Her message of 21 February 2024

“Incidentally, I wish you every success with the launch of the English-language edition of your book, which I read with great pleasure.” Page 1, the message of 21 February 2024, 18:22, at the top of the thread, signed by Karin Vaalburg. The sentence closes the paragraph about Giltay’s email of 14 February. Translated from the Dutch; the original wording is below.

“Ik wens u overigens bijzonder veel succes met de lancering van de Engelstalige uitgave van uw boek, dat ik met veel plezier heb gelezen.” Original wording

The sentence in the email of 21 February 2024 in which the Ombudsman’s senior legal adviser wishes the author success with the English edition of the book, which she says she read with great pleasure.
Extract from page 1 of the email thread: the message of 21 February 2024. Tap the image to enlarge.

Why this document matters

In 1999 the interview reports from the MID’s internal investigation were incorporated word for word, as the Min­is­ter’s official position, into a public Om­buds­man report that is still online today. A quarter of a century later the National Ombudsman’s own senior legal adviser, who according to the essay represented the Om­buds­man against Giltay in related court cases, read De doofpotgeneraal over her Christmas leave. In her work cor­re­spon­dence she praised the book’s documentation. The same thread shows what followed: she offered to discuss Giltay’s file, he proposed 27 February 2024 for the meeting in The Hague, and on 12 February she wrote that she had to forgo a follow-up meeting for the time being.

Provenance

Document
Email thread, PDF print from Gmail, five pages, twelve messages, printed 22 February 2024, 11:07
From
Karin Vaalburg, senior legal adviser (‘Senior juridisch adviseur’), National Ombudsman of the Netherlands
To
Edwin Giltay
Date
21 February 2024, 18:22, the most recent message, which is also the source of the second passage; the first passage is from the message of 9 January 2024, 14:11
Subject
“Re: Betaling griffie- en proceskosten zaaknummer SGR 23 / 6997 WOO” (‘Re: Payment of the court fee and legal costs, case number SGR 23 / 6997 WOO’)
Case number
SGR 23 / 6997 WOO, the appeal to the District Court of The Hague against the Ombudsman’s failure to decide in time on Giltay’s request under the Open Government Act (Woo)
Thread
Vaalburg 8 January 11:24 · Giltay 8 January 17:05 · Vaalburg 9 January 14:11, the message quoted here · Giltay 15 January 08:47 · Vaalburg 1 February 12:14 · Giltay 6 February 10:56 · Vaalburg 12 February 16:34 · Giltay 14 February 16:00 · Giltay 20 February 13:58 · Vaalburg 20 February 14:35 · Giltay 20 February 16:36 · Vaalburg 21 February 18:22, also quoted here
References
The judgment in case SGR 23 / 6997 WOO (ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2023:20409), sent 4 January 2024, which upheld the appeal · the Woo decision taken on 7 February 2024 · the €1,900 penalty payment that was made, and Giltay’s position that it should be €2,000 · the meeting at the Ombudsman’s office in The Hague, for which Giltay proposed 27 February 2024 as the date · the launch of the English edition on 6 April 2024
Referred to
The book, sent to Vaalburg as a PDF by Giltay with his email of 13 December 2023
Redactions
The direct telephone number in the signature block and Giltay’s bank account number
Language
Dutch
Pages
5
Held by
Author’s archive
See also
In­ter­nal in­ves­ti­ga­tion for the MID Chief of Staff, 12 February 1999Ministry of De­fence to the Na­tion­al Om­buds­man, 2 March 1999Na­tion­al Om­buds­man report 1999/507, 17 De­cem­ber 1999
Open the full PDF
Karin Vaalburg, senior legal adviser, National Ombudsman, emails to Edwin Giltay, 9 January and 21 February 2024, in the thread “Betaling griffie- en proceskosten zaaknummer SGR 23 / 6997 WOO”, printed from Gmail on 22 February 2024. Author’s archive. dedoofpotgeneraal.nl/doc/vaalburg.pdf.
Cited in: Exhibit page: https://www.dedoofpotgeneraal.nl/card/en/vaalburg.htm
Document: https://www.dedoofpotgeneraal.nl/doc/vaalburg.pdf
Last modified 3 August 2026, accessed 15 November 2026.
Front cover of The Cover-up General

This page is an exhibit to the book The Cover-up General by Edwin Giltay and its accompanying website.