Exhibit · Appraisal

Deloitte appraisal of Giltay, 6 April 2000

Working with colleagues

“Edwin has fitted in very well to a team comprising 14 different nationalities and his friendly, polite and professional manner has won him many friends. He also speaks good English.” Page 1, the paragraph above the closing paragraph. The document is in English. The scan clips the right edge of the frame, so the last letter of ‘polite’ is cut off at the end of the first line; the word is given here in full.

Scan of the paragraph of the Deloitte feedback form in which the manager writes that Edwin Giltay fitted in very well to a team of 14 nationalities and that his friendly, polite and professional manner won him many friends.
Extract from page 1 of the feedback form: the paragraph above the closing paragraph. Tap the image to enlarge.

The recommendation

“Edwin has proved to be a vital part of the project team, without whom the project office could not have functioned as efficiently or effectively as it has and I would have no hesitation in recommending him for a similar position.” Page 1, the closing paragraph of the form. The document is in English. The scan clips the right edge of the frame, so the last letter of ‘not’ is cut off at the end of the first line of that paragraph; the word is given here in full.

Scan of the boxed closing paragraph of the Deloitte feedback form, in which the manager writes that Edwin Giltay proved to be a vital part of the project team and that he would have no hesitation in recommending Giltay for a similar position.
Extract from page 1 of the feedback form: the closing paragraph. Tap the image to enlarge.

Why this document matters

In this feedback form of 6 April 2000 Giltay’s manager at Deloitte Consulting writes that he would have no hesitation in recommending Giltay for a similar position. The essay lists professional references from multinationals, among them IBM and Deloitte, as part of the considerable evidence contradicting the characterisation of Giltay that the Minister of Defence put on record in 1999 and never withdrew. That characterisation is still online today in the National Ombudsman’s public report.

The manager also writes that the work was always of the highest quality and delivered on time, and that Giltay fitted in very well with a team of 14 nationalities, in which his friendly, polite and professional manner won him many friends. The form dates from a year after the characterisation had been set down in black and white.

Provenance

Document
Feedback Form, one page
Issued by
Deloitte & Touche Consulting Group
Appraiser
Charles Vivian, Deloitte Consulting
Appraisee
Edwin Giltay
Date
Handwritten beside the signature as 06/04/00, read here as 6 April 2000
Subject
Appraisal of Giltay’s work in a project office set up to support a 70-person consulting engagement
Duties listed
Arranging hotel accommodation for the team of 70 consultants, developing and managing a project office website, collecting time data, assisting with the organisation of external meetings, establishing and managing documentation libraries
Redaction
The signature is blacked out in the scan; the handwritten name Charles Vivian and the line Deloitte Consulting beneath it are left legible
Language
English
Pages
1
Held by
Author’s archive
See also
Reference letter from IBM Nederland, 18 Oc­to­ber 1994Na­tion­al Om­buds­man report 1999/507, 17 De­cem­ber 1999
Open the full PDF
Deloitte & Touche Consulting Group, Feedback Form, appraisee E. Giltay, appraiser Charles Vivian, 6 April 2000, 1 p. Author’s archive. dedoofpotgeneraal.nl/doc/deloitte.pdf.
Cited in: the essay ‘The Ban Fell, the Book Stood’ in the chapter (3) ‘What the Book Reveals: The Srebrenica Cover-up’.
Exhibit page: https://www.dedoofpotgeneraal.nl/card/en/deloitte.htm
Document: https://www.dedoofpotgeneraal.nl/doc/deloitte.pdf
Last modified 13 September 2026, accessed 14 November 2026.
Front cover of The Cover-up General

This page is an exhibit to the book The Cover-up General by Edwin Giltay and its accompanying website.