“To date the Committee has not received from the Minister of Defence a request for advice on your complaint. The Committee is therefore unable at this time to investigate your complaint further.”
Page 1, the paragraph beginning “Tot op heden”. Translated from the Dutch; the original wording is below.
Original wording
“Tot op heden heeft de Commissie een verzoek om advies over uw klacht van de Minister van Defensie niet ontvangen. Derhalve kan de Commissie op dit moment uw klacht niet nader onderzoeken.”
Line breaks in the scan have been removed.
Extract from page 1 of the letter. Tap the image to enlarge.
Why this document matters
In June 2017 the Ministry of Defence refused to retract the 1999 ministerial declaration of insanity, citing an Ombudsman report and a CTIVD investigation that were said to have found Giltay’s complaints about the MIVD unfounded. The essay sets out that the CTIVD investigation, the second pillar, did not exist, and that this had been on the record since 2009.
This letter is the first of the two documents the essay points to: the committee writes that until then it had received no request from the Minister of Defence for advice on the complaint, and that it could not therefore investigate the complaint further at that time. In the same letter the committee explains that Article 83 of the Intelligence and Security Services Act 2002 obliges the Minister to seek its advice whenever he takes up a complaint about the MIVD.
Provenance
Document
Letter, one page, on the letterhead of the Review Committee on the Intelligence and Security Services
From
Commissie van Toezicht betreffende de Inlichtingen- en Veiligheidsdiensten (CTIVD), the Review Committee on the Intelligence and Security Services, Anna van Saksenlaan 50, 2593 HT The Hague
To
E. Giltay, The Hague
Date
12 January 2009
Reference
2009/0008
Subject
“Uw brief van 24 december 2008”, ‘your letter of 24 December 2008’
References
The letter replies to Giltay’s letter of 24 December 2008, which enclosed, among other things, his complaint of 1 September 2007 to the Minister of Defence
Legal basis cited
Article 83 of the Intelligence and Security Services Act 2002 (Wet op de inlichtingen- en veiligheidsdiensten 2002) and the complaints procedure of the General Administrative Law Act (Algemene wet bestuursrecht), under which the Minister of Defence must seek the committee’s advice when he takes up a complaint about the MIVD. The letter adds that under Article 9:8(1) of the General Administrative Law Act the Minister may decide not to handle a complaint, including where the conduct complained of was the subject of an earlier complaint already dealt with, or took place more than a year before the complaint was lodged
Signed
I.P. Michiels van Kessenich-Hoogendam, chair of the CTIVD, together with P.D. van Hees, the committee’s secretary. Both signatures are blacked out in the scan