Exhibit · Judgment

District Court of The Hague, judgment of 18 July 2023, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2023:17841

The Voices section quotes two sentences: the first appears in para. 4.8 of the judgment, the second in the summary on rechtspraak.nl. Both are set out below, with the judge’s conclusion between them.

Para. 4.8 · The decision is manifestly unlawful

“4.8. Now that it is established that the first option referred to under 4.6 above does not arise, and that the respondent has not refused the applicant’s authorised representative under Article 2:2 of the General Administrative Law Act, there is no obstacle whatsoever to the applicant’s representative submitting a Woo request on his behalf, nor is there any ground for then declining to consider that request by reference to other cases in which that representative is accused of abuse of rights. The contested decision is thus manifestly unlawful. The lack of urgency is therefore not held against the applicant in this case.” Para. 4.8, the last before the heading ‘Conclusie en gevolgen’ (‘Conclusion and consequences’). ‘Beletstel’ in the original is a slip for ‘beletsel’ (‘obstacle’) and has been left as it stands. Translated from the Dutch; the original wording is below.

“4.8. Nu vaststaat dat de hiervoor onder 4.6 genoemde eerste optie niet aan de orde is en de gemachtigde van verzoeker niet geweigerd is door verweerder op grond van artikel 2:2 van de Awb, bestaat geen enkel beletstel voor de gemachtigde van verzoeker om namens hem een Woo-verzoek in te dienen en bestaat evenmin een grond om dat verzoek vervolgens buiten behandeling te stellen met verwijzing naar andere zaken waarin die gemachtigde misbruik van recht wordt verweten. Daarmee is er sprake van een evidente onrechtmatigheid van het bestreden besluit. Het gebrek aan spoedeisend belang wordt verzoeker daarom in dit geval niet tegengeworpen.” Original wording

Para. 4.8 of the judgment, at the foot of page 5 and the top of page 6: there is no obstacle whatsoever to the applicant’s representative submitting a Woo request on his behalf, and the contested decision is manifestly unlawful.
Extract from page 5 of the copy, with the rest of the paragraph on page 6 below it. Tap the image to enlarge.

Paras 5.1 and 5.2 · Conclusion and consequences

“5.1. Since the contested decision is manifestly unlawful and further investigation cannot contribute to the assessment of the case, the preliminary relief judge sees reason to give judgment at once in the main action, applying Article 8:86, first paragraph, of the General Administrative Law Act. 5.2. The preliminary relief judge will declare the appeal well founded and quash the contested decision. This means that the respondent will still have to decide on the applicant’s request, having regard to this judgment.” Page 6 of the judgment, paras 5.1 and 5.2, under the heading ‘Conclusie en gevolgen’ (‘Conclusion and consequences’). ‘Verweerder’, ‘the respondent’, is the National Ombudsman. The operative part on page 7 lists the decisions in four lines: the appeal is declared well founded, the contested decision is quashed, a fresh decision on the Woo request is ordered, and the request for an interim measure is refused. The version published on deeplink.rechtspraak.nl/uitspraak?id=ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2023:17841 anonymises the applicant as [eiser] and his representative as [gemachtigde]. The copy on this site names the applicant, E.F. Giltay of The Hague. Para. 5.1 reads ‘onmiddellijk uitspraak doen’ where Dutch grammar requires ‘onmiddellijk uitspraak te doen’; the slip is in the original and has been left as it stands. Translated from the Dutch; the original wording is below.

“5.1. Nu het bestreden besluit evident onrechtmatig is en nader onderzoek niet kan bijdragen aan de beoordeling van de zaak, ziet de voorzieningenrechter reden om met toepassing van artikel 8:86, eerste lid, van de Awb onmiddellijk uitspraak doen in de hoofdzaak. 5.2. De voorzieningenrechter zal het beroep gegrond verklaren en het bestreden besluit vernietigen. Dit betekent dat verweerder alsnog zal moeten beslissen op het verzoek van verzoeker met inachtneming van deze uitspraak.” Original wording

Paras 5.1 and 5.2 on page 6 of the judgment, under the heading ‘Conclusie en gevolgen’ (‘Conclusion and consequences’): the appeal is declared well founded and the Ombudsman must still decide.
Extract from page 6 of the copy. Tap the image to enlarge.

Summary on rechtspraak.nl

“The contested decision is thus manifestly unlawful. The respondent must still issue a decision on the Woo request.” The last two sentences of the summary that rechtspraak.nl places above the published judgment. That summary is written by rechtspraak.nl and is not part of the judgment itself; the first sentence appears word for word in para. 4.8, the second sums up para. 5.2. ‘Verweerder’, ‘the respondent’, is the National Ombudsman. Translated from the Dutch; the original wording is below.

“Daarmee is er sprake van een evidente onrechtmatigheid van het bestreden besluit. Verweerder zal alsnog op het Woo-verzoek moeten beslissen.” Original wording

Why this document matters

In this judgment of 18 July 2023, the preliminary relief judge held that the National Ombudsman could not decline to consider Giltay’s request of 13 April 2023 under the Open Government Act (Woo) merely because abuse of rights had been assumed on the part of Giltay’s authorised representative. Moreover, the Ombudsman did not accuse Giltay himself of anything of the kind. The contested decision was therefore “manifestly unlawful”. The preliminary relief judge declared the appeal well founded and ordered the institution to take a fresh decision on the request. The essay states that the National Ombudsman broke off the correspondence and then blocked this request for government documents. A second judgment, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2023:20409, later imposed penalty payments for the failure to decide on another Woo request of 1 September 2023.

Provenance

Document
Judgment (uitspraak) of the preliminary relief judge, deciding the main action at the same time under Article 8:86 of the General Administrative Law Act (Awb)
Court
District Court of The Hague, Administrative Law Division, sitting at The Hague
Date
18 July 2023, delivered in open court; a copy was sent to the parties on 19 July 2023
Hearing
20 June 2023, heard together with the requests in cases SGR 23/2898, SGR 23/4651, SGR 23/4664, SGR 23/4666 and SGR 23/4668, each decided separately
Case numbers
SGR 23/4662 and SGR 23/4663
Case-law identifier
ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2023:17841
Parties
E.F. Giltay, of The Hague, applicant, assisted by an authorised representative, versus the National Ombudsman, respondent
Judge
D. Biever, preliminary relief judge; registrar Y.E. de Loos
Subject
Open Government Act (Wet open overheid, Woo); a request not considered, on the assumption of abuse of rights by the applicant’s authorised representative; anti-abuse provision in Article 4.6 of the Woo and refusal of a representative under Article 2:2 of the Awb
Request
Woo request of 13 April 2023 for all documents showing whether contact arrangements had been made about the applicant, whether his personal data had been linked in any file or list to such arrangements or to conduct attributed to him, whether staff had labelled him a difficult complainant, and whether any of that had been shared internally or externally
Contested decision
Decision of the National Ombudsman of 14 April 2023, which simultaneously declined to consider twelve Woo requests, citing abuse of rights
Outcome
Appeal declared well founded; contested decision quashed; a fresh decision on the Woo request ordered; the request for an interim measure refused
References
Paras 4.6 and 4.8 for the reasoning; paras 5.1 and 5.2 for the conclusion; operative part on page 7; the related judgment of 27 December 2023, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2023:20409, case number SGR 23/6997, imposing penalty payments
Language
Dutch
Published in
Rechtspraak.nl, 21 November 2023
Held by
Author’s archive (copy); the anonymised version with the Council for the Judiciary (Raad voor de rechtspraak), deeplink.rechtspraak.nl/uitspraak?id=ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2023:17841
Source
Not anonymised, at dedoofpotgeneraal.nl/doc/uitspraak.pdf (7 pages)
See also
National Ombudsman to Giltay, with Giltay’s letter of 13 March 2018, 10 April 2018
District Court of The Hague 18 July 2023, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2023:17841 (case numbers SGR 23/4662 and SGR 23/4663), paras 5.1 and 5.2.
Cited in: Exhibit page: https://www.dedoofpotgeneraal.nl/card/en/ecli-nl-rbdha-2023-17841.htm
Document: https://www.dedoofpotgeneraal.nl/doc/uitspraak.pdf
Last modified 13 September 2026, accessed 19 November 2026.
Front cover of The Cover-up General

This page is an exhibit to the book The Cover-up General by Edwin Giltay and its accompanying website.