Exhibit · Review

Boekje Pienter, five-star review, 2017

The passage

“In ‘De doofpotgeneraal’ nothing is what it seems. It is almost suffocating to read how the intelligence services (or was it the general himself?) band together to make life miserable for innocent citizens. And how tribal wars are fought within the intelligence services. […] Such a cover-up must be smothered.” Seventh of the twelve paragraphs, and the closing sentence of the review. Translated from the Dutch; the original wording is below. De doof­pot­ge­ne­raal is the book’s original Dutch title; the English edition is The Cover-up Gen­eral.

Original wording

“In ‘De doofpotgeneraal’ lijkt niets wat het is. Het is bijna verstikkend om te lezen hoe de inlichtingendiensten - of was het de generaal zelf? - te hoop lopen om onschuldige burgers het leven zuur te maken. En hoe er binnen de inlichtingendiensten stammenstrijden plaatsvinden. […] Zo’n doofpot moet gesmoord worden.” Quoted from the page as archived on 18 August 2017. The review sets the parenthesis between plain hyphens; the English rendering puts it in brackets. The book title appears in single quotation marks in the original.

Why this document matters

Boekje Pienter, a Dutch military reading guide, gives De doofpotgeneraal five stars out of five, the highest mark in the guide’s own key: ‘Absoluut lezen’ (‘absolutely worth reading’). The reviewer identifies the general of the title as Ad van Baal and calls the book almost suffocating to read. The review asks what became of the now world-famous Dutchbat roll of film and closes by saying that such a cover-up must be smothered. The Voices section counts this review among the star-rated reviews the book received.

Provenance

Document
Book review in the alphabetical reading guide, page Leeswijzer D, under the heading ‘DE DOOFPOTGENERAAL - EDWIN GILTAY’
Publication
Boekje Pienter, Dutch military reference site, www.boekje-pienter.nl, subtitled ‘“The way of life” van een militair’ (‘a serviceman’s way of life’)
Author
No reviewer named on the page; the review is written in the first person
Rating
Five stars out of five. According to the key at the foot of the page, that stands for ‘Absoluut lezen’ (‘absolutely worth reading’)
Reviewed work
Edwin Giltay, De doof­pot­ge­ne­raal. Overheidsspionage op de bedrijfsvloer, SpeakEasy, 2015 (the year given on the page; the first edition appeared in 2014), 198 pages, ISBN 9789492146007; the updated second and later editions were published by De Blauwe Tijger
Date
Undated. The entry is a bare listing without stars or text in the captures of 1 April 2016 and 28 December 2016, and carries the full five-star review in the capture of 11 May 2017, so the review appeared in the first months of 2017
Subject
The book, and the question of what General Ad van Baal did not want to become known
Quoted
Steven Derix and Floris van Straaten in NRC Handelsblad of 26 March 2001 on Van Baal, and Hans Laroes in the epilogue to the book
References
The fall of Srebrenica in 1995, the Dutchbat roll of film, the MIVD, and the cable company Casema
Language
Dutch
Held by
Internet Archive; the live site no longer serves the page; captures from June 2023 onwards return a redirect and a 404
Archived copy
web.archive.org/web/20170818215052/www.boekje-pienter.nl/html/leeswijzer-d.htm#dedoofpotgeneraal
Open the source
Review of Edwin Giltay, De doof­pot­ge­ne­raal (SpeakEasy, 2015), Leeswijzer D, Boekje Pienter, 2017. No reviewer named. Archived at web.archive.org/web/20170818215052/www.boekje-pienter.nl/html/leeswijzer-d.htm#dedoofpotgeneraal.
Cited in: the Voices section under the heading ‘Star Reviews’.
Exhibit page: https://www.dedoofpotgeneraal.nl/card/en/boekje-pienter.htm
Document: https://web.archive.org/web/20170818215052/www.boekje-pienter.nl/html/leeswijzer-d.htm
Accessed 15 November 2026.
Front cover of The Cover-up General

This page is an exhibit to the book The Cover-up General by Edwin Giltay and its accompanying website.